Not what you're
looking for? Try an advanced search.
Buy This Entire Record For
Commonwealth v. Green
Superior Court of Pennsylvania
September 4, 2013
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA, Appellee
HARRY GREEN, Appellant
Appeal from the Judgment of Sentence entered December 16, 2011 In the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County Criminal Division at No(s): CP-02-CR-0001065-2011 CP-02-CR-0013983-2010
BEFORE: BENDER, J., LAZARUS, J., and STRASSBURGER, J.[*]
Appellant, Harry Green, appeals from the judgment of sentence of an aggregate term of 21 ½ - 43 years' incarceration following his conviction for third-degree murder and a violation of the Uniform Firearms Act. Appellant claims the trial court erred in its resolution of several evidentiary issues. After careful review, we affirm.
The events that gave rise to Appellant's trial for murder were recounted by the trial court as follows:
On the afternoon of August 9, 2010, [the Victim] was shot by her boyfriend, [Appellant], in her apartment on Deraud Street in the Hill District section of Pittsburgh. [The Victim] died of a gunshot wound to the head, with a single bullet having entered her head below her right eye. The bullet was recovered [from the] inside [of her] skull. Mr. Terrence Lee, a friend of the [V]ictim and acquaintance of [Appellant], was at the apartment at the time of the shooting and identified [Appellant] as the shooter.2
2 Terrence Lee's trial testimony recanted his earlier statements to police. However, this court found the earlier statements to the police to be credible and compelling, as well as consistent with other evidence in the case. Mr. Lee had explained to the [V]ictim's mother that he was anxious about being threatened for his statements to police.
According to the testimony at trial, in the time leading up to the shooting, [Appellant] and [the Victim] had been arguing. [The Victim] had expressed, to a friend and family members, her intentions to break off her relationship with [Appellant]. She was discussing with her friends and family her plans to move from the Hill District to the East Hills. The move was going to be financed by an old boyfriend. Several hours prior to the shooting, [Appellant] overheard one such heated discussion between [the Victim] and her sister, Khalia. Within minutes of overhearing that conversation, [Appellant] and [the Victim] had an argument, during which [Appellant] took [the Victim]'s cell phone. As [Appellant] left [the Victim]'s apartment, [the Victim]'s sister, Khalia, was able to see a gun on the right side of his hip. After visiting a friend following her argument with [Appellant], [the Victim] returned to her apartment to wait for [Appellant] to return her cell phone.
The fact that [Appellant] had taken [the Victim]'s cell phone was confirmed by several witnesses. The [V]ictim's sister saw the cell phone in [Appellant]'s hand. The [V]ictim's mother, Barbara Robinson, testified that she was at the [V]ictim's apartment several times in the late morning/early afternoon to pick up her daughter, but stated that [the Victim] would not go with her until [Appellant] returned her phone. Additionally, the [V]ictim indicated to her friend, Janai Curry, that [Appellant] had her cell phone and she was waiting for him to return it to her.
According to the recorded statement that Mr. Lee gave to the police on the night of the shooting, [Appellant] was at [the Victim]'s apartment, engaged in an argument with her, upon Mr. Lee's arrival at the apartment, which was approximately fifteen (15) minutes prior to the shooting. Mr. Lee told the police that, after some period of argument, [Appellant] got up to leave the apartment. As he was walking out the door, the [V]ictim said something to [Appellant], at which point [Appellant] turned toward her, pulled his gun, and shot her in the face. [The Victim] immediately fell to the floor. Mr. Lee initially grabbed [the Victim], then ran outside, looking upstairs of [the Victim]'s apartment, and yelled to the upstairs neighbor, Floorine Turner, to call an ambulance.
Ms. Turner's daughter-in-law, who was also in the upstairs apartment, called the police, and Ms. Turner proceeded downstairs, first to [the Victim]'s sister's apartment and then to the [V]ictim's apartment. As she was descending the stairs, she saw [Appellant] going in and out of the front door. [Appellant] was saying that he was sorry and to [take] care of "my baby." Ms. Turner also overheard Mr. Lee telling [Appellant] that he needed to get out of there. Ms. Turner positively identified [Appellant], Harry Green, as the [V]ictim's boyfriend and as the person going in and out of the apartment door.
Ms. Janai Curry, who had spent time with [the Victim] that afternoon in the hours before the shooting and whom [the Victim] had told that she wanted to leave [Appellant], also saw [Appellant] after the shooting. As she was walking down the street, returning to her home, she received a frantic telephone call from Mr. Lee using the [V]ictim's phone. The fact that [the Victim]'s cell phone was back at her apartment confirm[ed] [Appellant]'s presence at the scene. The telephone call informed her of the shooting that had just occurred. Ms. Curry then immediately saw [Appellant] leaving the area of the [V]ictim's apartment and walking down the nearby city steps. Ms. Curry testified credibly that she observed that he was wearing a white shirt with blood on the front of it.
Both Mr. Lee and Ms. Turner positively identified [Appellant] via photo array when questioned by police. Mr. Lee also relayed what he had witnessed to the [V]ictim's mother and described the events leading up to the shooting to her. Ms. Turner, an unbiased witness with no real connection to anyone ...
Buy This Entire Record For