Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Official citation and/or docket number and footnotes (if any) for this case available with purchase.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

In Re: Asbestos Products Liability Litigation (No. Vi)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA


November 16, 2012

IN RE: ASBESTOS PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION (NO. VI)

The opinion of the court was delivered by: David R. Strawbridge United States Magistrate Judge

This Document Relates to: E.D. Pa. No: FERGUSON v. A.C. AND S., INC. as well as the other cases on the attached list (all CVLO cases):

ORDER

AND NOW , this 16th day of November, 2012, upon consideration of the following motions, responses, replies, and motions for joinder, as well as plaintiffs' omnibus response (10-67443, Doc. 191) and the September 13, 2012 oral argument on the motions:

1. Defendant CBS Corporation's Motions for Sanctions (10-68073 Doc. 153; 08-90234 Doc. 73) and responses (10-68073 Doc. 172; 08-90234 Doc. 86);

2. Defendant Duke Energy Indiana, Inc's Motion to Strike (08-89340 Doc. 96) and response (08-89340 Doc. 100);

3. General Electric Company's Motion to Strike (08-90058 Doc. 106; 08-90263 Doc. 96; 08-90132 Doc. 102; 08-90122 Doc. 112; 08-90063 Doc. 97; 08-90166 Doc. 110), responses (08-90058 Doc. 114; 08-90263 Doc. 100; 08-90132 Doc. 106; 08-90122 Doc. 115; 08-90063 Doc. 102; 08-90166 Doc. 118) and replies (e.g. 08-90058 Doc. 116); and

4. Owens-Illinois, Inc.'s Motions to Strike (09-60552 Doc. 93; 10-67814 Doc. 114; 09-60256 Doc. 82; 09-61026 Doc. 106; 10-67443 Doc. 175; 11-63501 Doc. 155; 08-90058 Doc. 104; 08-90132 Doc. 101; 08-90263 Doc. 95; 08-90166 Doc. 107; 10-67555 Doc. 116; 11-66746 Doc. 176; 11-63483 Doc. 352) and responses (09-60552 Doc. 102; 09-60256 Doc. 89; 09-61026 Doc. 114; 11-63501 Doc. 164; 08-90132 Doc. 105; 08-90263 Doc. 99; 10-67555 Doc. 118; 11-66746 Doc. 182; 11-63483 Doc. 362);

it is hereby ORDERED that:

5. All motions for joinder are GRANTED ;

6. CBS Corporation's Motions for Sanctions in Plue, (10-68073 Doc. 153) and Ferguson, (08-90243 Doc. 73) are DENIED ;

7. The remaining motions listed above are GRANTED in part as described in the attached memorandum in that all interrogatory responses which were not verified by the Plaintiffs are struck; and

8. all other relief requested is DENIED .

BY THE COURT:

/s/ David R. Strawbridge

CASE LIST

Krik Charles 11-CV-63473 Top Ten Menozzi Eugene 08-CV-89865 1&2 Subgroup A Carnegie John 08-CV-89958 1&2 Subgroup A Hollins Willie 08-CV-90201 1&2 Subgroup A Winslow Terry 08-CV-92114 1&2 Subgroup A Johnson Richard 08-CV-92122 1&2 Subgroup A Weber Daniel 08-CV-92132 1&2 Subgroup A Hutchinson Jack 08-CV-92157 1&2 Subgroup A O'Keefe Robert 08-CV-92210 1&2 Subgroup A Frankenberger Howard 09-CV-61717 1&2 Subgroup A McCullum Roosevelt 08-CV-89883 1&2 Subgroup B De Witt Elsie 08-CV-90189 1&2 Subgroup B Centers Albert 08-CV-90268 1&2 Subgroup B Smith Ronald 08-CV-90287 1&2 Subgroup B Wilson Merle 08-CV-91879 1&2 Subgroup B Pray Frankie 08-CV-91884 1&2 Subgroup B Buchanan Howard 08-CV-92038 1&2 Subgroup B Black John 10-CV-68110 1&2 Subgroup B Malone Clifford 10-CV-68124 1&2 Subgroup B Ferguson James 08-CV-90234 1&2 Subgroup C Norberg Earl 08-CV-90264 1&2 Subgroup C Bault Charles 08-CV-91663 1&2 Subgroup C Bugg William 08-CV-91729 1&2 Subgroup C Schurtz Michael 08-CV-91742 1&2 Subgroup C Spangler Herbert 08-CV-91882 1&2 Subgroup C Thomas Glendel 08-CV-92206 1&2 Subgroup C Henney Jean 09-CV-64629 1&2 Subgroup C Allen Gary 10-CV-67536 1&2 Subgroup C Plue Richard 10-CV-68073 1&2 Subgroup C Dover Jackie 10-CV-68127 1&2 Subgroup C Cummings Ronald 10-CV-68902 1&2 Subgroup C Doyle James 08-CV-89845 3 Haffner Robert 08-CV-89863 3 Larweth Dennis 08-CV-89914 3 Wilson Harold 08-CV-90732 3 Childs Earl 08-CV-91089 3 Suoja Oswald 09-CV-60256 3 Hass Laverne 09-CV-60267 3 Hass Laverne 09-CV-60298 3 Meagher John 09-CV-60445 3 Connell Daniel 09-CV-60552 3 Obermeier Sylvester 09-CV-61019 3 Schmoll Cyril 09-CV-61026 3 Morris Michael 09-CV-61495 3 Waltenberg Claude 09-CV-61499 Vradenburg Stanley 09-CV-62185 3 Woods James 09-CV-62583 3 Willocks Tommy 09-CV-64701 3 Stephens John 09-CV-64733 3 Rickey Marvin 10-CV-61345 3 Lorentz Eugene 10-CV-61348 3 Sutherlin James 10-CV-64565 3 Collins Arthur 10-CV-64567 3 Louis Richard 10-CV-64606 3 Cadotte Joseph 10-CV-64680 3 Ahnert Daniel 10-CV-67443 3 Held Donald 10-CV-67814 3 Binder Robert 10-CV-67817 3 Jakubowski Florian 10-CV-67831 3 Andris Arthur 10-CV-67885 3 Hakes Donald 10-CV-68063 3 Reed Hugh 08-CV-88250 4 Austin Richard 08-CV-89340 4 Heggie JW 08-CV-89372 4 McFarland Charles 08-CV-89381 4 Cook Joseph 08-CV-89446 4 Kemper Jack 08-CV-89498 4 Fata Frank 08-CV-90058 4 Schmidt Donald 08-CV-90063 4 Phillips John 08-CV-90122 4 Jones Asa 08-CV-90132 4 Willey Russel 08-CV-90166 4 Jackson Floyd 08-CV-90263 4 Percy Warren 08-CV-90465 4 Weber Ronald 08-CV-91052 4 Holme Darrell 08-CV-91090 4 Baker Joseph 08-CV-91189 4 Bolton John 09-CV-60186 4 Esser Charles 09-CV-60287 4 Bresnahan Thomas 09-CV-60331 4 Jones Duane 09-CV-60440 4 Lundahl Robert 09-CV-60444 4 Sienko Ronald 09-CV-60481 4 Jeske Kenneth 09-CV-60547 4 Junk Bonnie 09-CV-60550 4 Nuutinen Charles 09-CV-61333 4 Frisch Louis 09-CV-61354 4 Schroeder Cletus 09-CV-61430 4 Crumwell Richard 09-CV-61744 4 Ruesken Louis 09-CV-61820 4 Giuliano William 09-CV-64609 Ringo Robert 09-CV-91454 4 Bennington Martin 10-CV-61115 4 Pietrzycki Stanley 10-CV-61349 4 Suhaysik Raymond 10-CV-61865 4 Dittamore William 10-CV-64583 4 Embly Robert 10-CV-64584 4 Kelley Howard 10-CV-67555 4 Arseneault Clovis 10-CV-67621 4 Gosz Clarence 10-CV-67808 4 Risse Loren 10-CV-67857 4 Patrick Homer 10-CV-68864 4 Herr Richard 11-CV-60064 4 Van Stippen Joseph 11-CV-63483 4 Strerath William 11-CV-63496 4 Brazzoni Alfred 11-CV-63501 4 Tischer Daniel 11-CV-63503 4 Muehlberger Max 11-CV-63518 4 Johnson Francis 11-CV-66278 4 Zellner Clifford 11-CV-66746 4 Kirk Delbert 08-CV-89494 5 Riggs Irving 08-CV-91762 5 Hicks William 08-CV-91888 5 Maulding Duane 08-CV-92113 5 Walker Clarence 08-CV-92136 5 Serstad Richard 09-CV-60165 5 Loeffelad Walter 09-CV-60231 5 Caturia Frederick 09-CV-60271 5 Akey Richard 09-CV-60286 5 Reno Charles 09-CV-60293 5 Dunne Michael 09-CV-60329 5 Burns John 09-CV-60476 5 Schulze Ronald 09-CV-60516 5 Miller Frank 09-CV-60520 5 Reich Ronald 09-CV-60523 5 Enerson Donald 09-CV-61004 5 Flaatten Ronald 09-CV-61006 5 Jelinski Jerome 09-CV-61012 5 White Paul 09-CV-61033 5 Holcomb Edward 09-CV-61314 5 Metzger Jack 09-CV-61322 5 Rathsack Michael 09-CV-61347 5 Gabrus Donald 09-CV-61357 5 Horton Julius 09-CV-61469 5 Ketchum Richard 09-CV-61481 5 Reichert Norman 09-CV-61487 5 Kiepert William 09-CV-61544 Enos Carroll 10-CV-61422 5 Kumferman Henry 10-CV-61429 5 Bartlett Robert 10-CV-61467 5 Gottsacker Randall 10-CV-61885 5 Zimmer Lawrence 10-CV-61896 5 Nelson Marlin 10-CV-61956 5 Sebastian Sigfried 10-CV-64686 5 Wagner Edward 10-CV-67704 5 Berger Thomas 10-CV-67758 5 Conway Harold 10-CV-67785 5 Hickmann Eugene 10-CV-67805 5 Junk William 10-CV-67841 5 Irons Gary 10-CV-68130 5 Bucknell Bertha 11-CV-63908 5 Reno Charles 11-CV-67724 5 Oliphant John 11-CV-67767 5 Dice James 08-CV-88411 6 Bartlett Thomas 08-CV-89791 6 Rome Douglas 08-CV-89825 6 Czajkoski Walter 08-CV-89969 6 Klimek David 08-CV-90065 6 Matlock Benjamin 08-CV-90099 6 Graham Marion 08-CV-90139 6 Hamerla John 08-CV-90208 6 Patrick Carolyn 08-CV-90221 6 Woodmaster Charles 08-CV-91087 6 Gard Leslie 08-CV-91736 6 Van Dolah Vernon 08-CV-91880 6 Graves William 08-CV-92120 6 Lawless Anthony 08-CV-92161 6 Massey Leonard 09-CV-61356 6 Deters Cletus 10-CV-64585 6 Richardson Eleanore 10-CV-67553 6 Nichols Gerald 10-CV-68097 6 Toon Lloyd 08-CV-88707 7 Brown Gary 08-CV-89945 7 Bey George 08-CV-89979 7 Brigham George 08-CV-89984 7 White Shirley 08-CV-90171 7 Smith Leo 08-CV-90276 7 Scott Thomas 08-CV-91314 7 Taylor James 08-CV-91881 7 Nehlsen Michael 08-CV-91893 7 Ayers Mark 08-CV-91953 7 Daniels Jimmie 08-CV-92259 7 Engelman Patrick 09-CV-60939 Campbell Elmer 10-CV-61341 7 Benson Harold 10-CV-64563 7 Carlson Neil 10-CV-67533 7 Carmichael James 10-CV-67545 7 Cyril Svatek 11-CV-64036 7 Jurglanis Clemens 12-CV-60003 7 Spychalla Leonard 12-CV-60004 7 Eulgen Louis 12-CV-60019 7 Krueger Glenn 12-CV-60020 7 Pehlke Luella 12-CV-60049 7 McNair Mary 12-CV-60160 Certificate of Service

MAILED: ALBERT BOWER DEREK SMITH KELLY CHERF RICHARD BOLTON AMBER ACHILLES DEVLIN SCHOOP KELLY MCCLOSKEY RICHARD CHAPIN ANDREW WOLF DONALD BERGER KENNETH GORENBERG RICHARD HAAS

BARRY ROBIN DONALD BROAD KEVIN LONG RICHARD STEINKEN BEAU SEFTON ELIZABETH HARVEY KEVIN REID ROBERT HALEY BILLEE WARD FRANCIS MORRISSEY KRISTIN ACHTERHOF ROBERT KOPKA

BRADLEY FALKOF GARY SMITH LAURA O'CONNELL RONALD CURTIS BRIAN CAHILL J. GASS LEON TODD RONALD LIPINSKI BRIAN FIELDS JACK BLOCK LISA WARWICK RONALD WELDY BRIAN PLEGGE JACQUELYN CHAMPAGNE LORI YOKOYAMA ROSEANNE LOFTUS BRUCE KAMPLAIN JAMES CULHANE MARK JOHNSON RUSSELL HOOVER BRUCE MARR JAMES FIEWEGER MARK LIES SCOTT KYROUAC C. KOEBELE JAMES PECKERT MARK RAKOCZY SEAN MACK CAROL PRYGROSKY JAMES SNYDER MATTHEW LEE STACEY SENECZKO CHARLES BOHL JAMES WHEELER MAUREEN KELLY STEPHEN KAUFMANN CHARLES DARGO JAN DODD MELISSA SKILKEN STEPHEN KRAVIT CHARLES REITER JEFFREY MCKEAN MICHAEL BISHOP STEPHEN MAASSEN CHRISTOPHER RAISTRICK JEFFREY SCHMECKPEPER MICHAEL CIESLEWICZ STEVEN CELBA CLARKE GILLESPIE JENNIFER FARDY MICHAEL HENNIG STEVEN SANDERS CREED TUCKER JENNIFER SEIDLER MICHAEL KAEDING SUSAN GUNTY D. GLOOR JEROME KRINGS MICHAEL KOKAL SUSAN HUNTER DANIEL FARROLL JOAN IRICK MICHAEL O'ROURKE THADDEUS STANKOWSKI DANIEL OVERBEY JOEL POOLE MICHELLE MONTGOMERY THOMAS EHRHARDT DAVID BARTEL JOHN CHILDERS PAMELA PAIGE THOMAS MEYER DAVID MORRIS JOHN DAMES PATRICK HAGGERTY THOMAS WILSON DAVID MUELLER JOHN DIXON PATRICK JONES TIMOTHY FAGAN DAVID ROLF JOHN STUCKEY PATRICK MCKENNA TIMOTHY UEBER DEAN PANOS JOSEPH O'HARA PATRICK PHILLIPS VANI SINGHAL DEBORAH SOLMOR JOSEPH WITEK PETER CARLSON VICTOR LAZZARETTI DEMARCUS GORDON JOSHUA MURPHY PETER HATTON W. WELSH DENIS RISCHARD JUAN RAMIREZ R. MUTH WILLIAM EHRKE DENNIS DOBBELS K. CAREY R. STOMMEL WILLIAM HASSLER DENNIS GRABER KARL KOONS RICHARD BAKER WILLIAM MCGRATH ZANE LUCAS

E-MAILED: ADAM JAGADICH DOUGLAS KING JOSEPH SULLIVAN REED SUGG ADAM LAGOCKI DOUGLAS PROCHNOW JOSHUA JOHANNINGMEIER RICHARD LAUTH AHNDREA VANDENELZEN DREW ODUM JOSHUA LEE RICHARD RIEGNER ALLEN VAUGHAN EDWARD CASMERE KAREN RHEINGANS RICHARD SCHUSTER

AMANDA SUMMERLIN EDWARD CRANE KATHERINE SPITZ ROBERT LONG

AMIEL GROSS EDWARD KENNEY KATHRYN DOWNEY ROBERT MCCOY ANDREW DETHERAGE EDWARD MACCABE KAYCE GISINGER ROBERT PISANI ANTHONY GOLDNER EDWARD MCCAMBRIDGE KEITH HAYS ROBERT RALEIGH BARBARA BUBA EMILY ZAPOTOCNY KENT PLOTNER ROBERT RILEY BARRY LOFTUS ERIC CARLSON KENT ROGERS ROBERT SANDS BARRY SHORT FORREST WILKES KEVIN KNIGHT ROBERT SCHROEDER

BASIL DISIPIO GARY SMITH KIMBERLY HILLMAN ROBERT SCOTT BETH HUGHES GEORGE KISER KIMBERLY SARFF ROBERT SPINELLI BRADLEY BULTMAN GERMAINE WILLETT KIRK HARTLEY ROBERT SPITKOVSKY BRADLEY NAHRSTADT GREGORY COCHRAN KNIGHT ANDERSON ROGER HEIDENREICH BRETT LARSEN GREGORY GOLDBERG KRISTINA LEMANSKI RONALD AUSTIN

BRIAN WATSON GREGORY LYONS KURT REITZ RONALD HACK BRUCE CLARK GREGORY MCNAMEE KURTIS REEG RUSSELL KLINGAMAN BRYAN SKELTON HEIDI RUCKMAN LANCE MUELLER RUSSELL SCOTT BRYCE BENNETT HOWARD MORRIS LAUREL JOHNSON SARAH MILLER

Certificate of Service

C. DOUGLAS J. BRADLEY LAURIE MCLEROY SARAH PAGELS C. EVERT J. MALONEY LAURIE RANDOLPH SCOTT HENRY CARMEN ANDERSON JACOB SAWYER LESLEY SHERMETA SCOTT SIMPKINS CAROL ZUCKERMAN JAMES BOYERS LISA DILLMAN SCOTT THOMSEN CATHERINE CARLSON JAMES CARTER M. GRANT SEAN SHEEHAN CATHERINE MOHAN JAMES HOUSE MAJA EATON SHAWANE LEE

CATHY MOLCHIN JAMES KASPER MARGARET FOSTER SHAWN BABIUCH CHAN MCLEOD JAMES MORRISON MARK EISLER SHEHZAD HASAN CHARLES JOLEY JAMES MURRAY MARK FELDMANN SHEILA BIRNBAUM CHRISTI JONES JAMES NIQUET MARK LUDOLPH STEPHEN JENKINS CHRISTOPHER BANASZAK JAMES SVAJGL MARK SAMPSON STEPHEN MILOTT CHRISTOPHER CONRAD JAMES WALTON MARK TIVIN STEPHEN SCHWARTZ CHRISTOPHER LARSON JAMES WYNNE MARTHA REGGI STEVEN BARBER CHRISTOPHER LEE JAMIE YADGAROFF MARTIN SCHWARTZ STEVEN BESHORE CHRISTOPHER P.BANASZAK JANELLE LINDER MARY ANN HATCH STEVEN CARLSON CHRISTOPHER TRIBLE JASON CINCILLA MARY GAY STEVEN KIRSCH CHRISTOPHER WAHL JASON KENNEDY MATTHEW FISCHER SUSAN MEHRINGER

CLARE MAISANO JASON RUBIN MATTHEW JARDINE TEIRNEY CHRISTENSON CLARE RUSH JEFFREY FULTZ MATTHEW THIBODEAU THOMAS CANNON CONNIE POSTELLI JEFFREY HEBRANK MAUREEN COLEMAN THOMAS GILLIGAN CRAIG BRASFIELD JEFFREY ROGERS MELISSA SMITH THOMAS GONZALEZ CRAIG LILJESTRAND JEFFREY SCHIEBER MICAH INLOW THOMAS HAYES CRAIG TURET JENNIFER BLACKWELL MICHAEL ANTIKAINEN THOMAS KERNELL CURTIS BAILEY JENNIFER KALAS MICHAEL BERGIN THOMAS NORBY CYNTHIA LOCKE JENNIFER STUDEBAKER MICHAEL BLOCK THOMAS ORRIS DANIEL CHEELY JEREMY HARRIS MICHAEL CASCINO THOMAS SCHMITZER DANIEL DONAHUE JIN-HO CHUNG MICHAEL DENNING THOMAS SCHRIMPF DANIEL ELGER JOHN BABIONE MICHAEL DRUMKE THOMAS TARDY DANIEL GRIFFIN JOHN CANONI MICHAEL ROSENBERG THOMAS THIBODEAU DANIEL JARDINE JOHN DOUGLAS MICHAEL TRUCCO TIFFANY TURNER DANIEL LONG JOHN FONSTAD MICHAEL ZUKOWSKI TIMOTHY KAPSHANDY DANIEL MANNA JOHN HELLER MITCHELL MOSER TIMOTHY KRIPPNER

DANIEL MCGRATH JOHN KUROWSKI NATHAN FRONK TIMOTHY PAGEL DANIEL MULHOLLAND JOHN LAFFEY NATHANIEL CADE TIMOTHY PIKE DANIEL O'CONNELL JOHN MCCANTS NEAL MCQUEENEY TOBIN TAYLOR DANIEL TRACHTMAN JOHN SEEBOHM NICHOLAS NIZAMOFF TRACY COWAN DAVID DAMICO JOHN SHEFFER NICOLE BEHNEN TREVOR WILL DAVID DOGAN JOHN SON OLLIE HARTON W. SIESENNOP

DAVID FANNING JOHN WALLER PATRICK FINNEGAN WALTER JENKINS DAVID JONES JON BAROOSHIAN PATRICK LAMB WALTER WATKINS DAVID SETTER JON FREDRICKSON PATRICK STUFFLEBEAM WARD BROWN DAVID SZLANFUCHT JON GOLDWOOD PAUL O'FLAHERTY WAYNE MARVEL DAVID TEMPLE JONATHAN MATTINGLY PAUL WOJCICKI WILLIAM CROKE DAVID YBARRA JONATHAN PARRINGTON PETER MARKS WILLIAM MAHONEY DEMETRA CHRISTOS JOSEPH CAGNOLI PETER MCKENNA WILLIAM SERRITELLA DENNIS CANTRELL JOSEPH KRASOVEC R. WILLINGHAM WILLIAM SHULTZ DONALD CARLSON JOSEPH REJANO RAYMOND FOURNIE WILLIAM SMITH RAYMOND MODESITT WILLIS TRIBLER

20121116

© 1992-2012 VersusLaw Inc.



Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Official citation and/or docket number and footnotes (if any) for this case available with purchase.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.