IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
June 20, 2011
GENERAL REFRACTORIES COMPANY
FIRST STATE INSURANCE CO., ET AL. LEXINGTON INSURANCE COMPANY : AIU INSURANCE COMPANY
The opinion of the court was delivered by: Ludwig, J.
This action was remanded by our Court of Appeals upon reversal of order of September 27, 2005 that dismissed the action for lack of necessary parties, 500 F.3d 306 (2007). The statement of facts set forth in the appellate decision is incorporated here by reference.
In this litigation, plaintiff General Refractories Company sues 14 insurance carriers for a declaration of excess insurance coverage against asbestos-related claims. A manufacturer and supplier of asbestos-containing products, GRC is a defendant in numerous asbestos-related suits throughout the United States. Two of those insurance carriers are Lexington Insurance Company and AIU Insurance Company.
As to each of those defendants, GRC moved for partial summary judgment
(doc. nos. 277 and 278, respectively), contending that their policies
of insurance did not contain an exclusion pertinent to asbestos
products. Before those motions were ruled on, Lexington and AIU were
permitted to amend their joint answer to add counterclaims for
rescission of the policies.*fn1 (Order, Mar. 24, 2011,
doc. no. 304. Counterclaims, doc. no. 284 at 29-37.) As of June 8,
2011, GRC now moves for partial summary judgment as to those
counterclaims on the same ground (doc. no. 315).
Discovery has been completed, and the following facts are not in dispute. None of the policies or a policy endorsement has an exclusion for asbestos-related claims.*fn2 Both defendants concede as much, but assert the intent of the parties to include such an exclusion can be shown by extrinsic evidence. That issue -- whether these policies should be deemed to contain asbestos-related exclusions -- is presented in GRC's third pending motion for partial summary judgment (doc. no. 315) and is deferred. Today's orders hold that there is no exclusion stated in the policies or an endorsement.
BY THE COURT: /s/ Edmund V. Ludwig Edmund V. Ludwig, J.