Searching over 5,500,000 cases.

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Official citation and/or docket number and footnotes (if any) for this case available with purchase.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.



decided: May 23, 1986.


Appeal from the Order of the Adjutant General, Department of Military Affairs, in case of In the Matter of Claim of David W. Knauer, Petition No. 83-1, dated February 21, 1985.


David W. Knauer, Cleckner and Fearen, for petitioner.

Michael B. Sutton, Deputy Attorney General, with him, Andrew S. Gordon, Chief Deputy Attorney General, Chief Litigation Section, and LeRoy S. Zimmerman, Attorney General, for respondents.

Judges Craig and Colins, and Senior Judge Barbieri, sitting as a panel of three. Opinion by Judge Colins.

Author: Colins

[ 97 Pa. Commw. Page 433]

On July 10, 1977, David W. Knauer (Petitioner) was injured when a desk was dropped on his knee while he was on annual field training with the Pennsylvania National Guard. This injury prevents petitioner from participating in strenuous physical activity, including military duty. As a result of this injury, on December 9, 1983, the petitioner applied for military disability benefits with the Department of Military Affairs (Department) pursuant to Section 3501 of the Military Code (Code), 51 Pa. C.S. ยง 3501. On February 21, 1985, the Adjutant General of the Department denied petitioner's application on the grounds that petitioner had not shown a loss of earning power under The Pennsylvania Workmen's Compensation Act,*fn1 and was therefore not entitled to military disability compensation under Section 3501 of the Code. This appeal followed.

We need only address the first of the issues raised by the parties, specifically whether an injury sustained while on Federally mandated and Federally funded annual field training is the type of injury for which a guardsman may be compensated pursuant to the provisions of Section 3501 of the Code. Section 3501 of the Code provides:

(a) General Rule. -- If any officer or enlisted man of the Pennsylvania National Guard is injured or otherwise disabled, or dies as a result of injuries or other disability received or contracted while performing duty in active service of the Commonwealth or in the performance of other State military duty under competent order or authority, or while engaged in volunteer service during a civil emergency at the request of competent military authority, he or his dependents,

[ 97 Pa. Commw. Page 434]

    if not compensated therefor by the government of the United States, shall receive from the Commonwealth just and reasonable relief, the amount of compensation to be determined in accordance with the Workmen's Compensation Law of Pennsylvania [citation omitted]. The General Assembly shall appropriate the moneys necessary to provide for such compensation.

It is self-evident that participation in annual training is not active service for the state, nor is it volunteer service during a civil emergency. Therefore, for petitioner to be entitled to benefits, annual training must be the performance of other State military duty. Unfortunately for petitioner, our Supreme Court has recently held that annual training is not State military duty.*fn2 Department of Military Affairs and Pennsylvania National Guard v. Greenwood, 510 Pa. 348, 508 A.2d 292 (1986). The General Assembly intended to implement a system of state military benefits to be applicable only when a Pennsylvania National Guardsman is engaged in distinctively state military service. Id. The essentially federal character of annual training precludes such from being considered "other State military duty." Therefore, petitioner's claim does not come within the purview of Section 3501 of the Code, and we are constrained to find that he is ineligible for any compensation.

The Department's order is, accordingly, affirmed.


And Now, May 23, 1986, the order of the Department of Military Affairs, dated February 21, 1985, is hereby affirmed.



Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Official citation and/or docket number and footnotes (if any) for this case available with purchase.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.