Appeal from the Order of the Pennsylvania Horse Racing Commission in case of In Re: Julius Paoli, No. 80-090.
Edward Reif, for petitioner.
Gerald T. Osburn, with him John B. Hannum, Jr., for respondent.
President Judge Crumlish, Jr. and Judges Williams, Jr. and Blatt, sitting as a panel of three. Opinion by President Judge Crumlish, Jr.
[ 81 Pa. Commw. Page 180]
Paoli appeals a Horse Racing Commission order suspending him for six months and fining him $1,000.*fn1 We affirm in part and reverse in part, remanding for appropriate penalty.
Paoli, a horse trainer, was ordered to have his animal take a blood and urine test. The Commission
[ 81 Pa. Commw. Page 181]
found that an analysis of the sample which allegedly was taken from his mount disclosed the presence of a prohibited drug, acepromazine. Also, certain prohibited drugs and hypodermic equipment were found in his tack room. The evidence supports the Board's conclusion that Paoli was in possession of certain prohibited drug paraphernalia, a violation of the Commission's rules, but there was no evidence that the seven hypodermic needles contained any trace of acepromazine.
Paoli contends that there is insufficient evidence of record to establish that the sample was in fact procured from his animal, notwithstanding the fact that urine sample number 06314 was marked positive for acepromazine, and there is evidence that Paoli's horse was tested. There is no evidence to support the Board's finding of fact that the sample, acepromazine, was indeed procured from Paoli's horse. Without this vital causal link, we must hold that the Commission's finding that Paoli's horse carried a prohibited drug in his body is not supported by substantial evidence.
Accordingly, we affirm that part of the Commission's decision which found Paoli to be in violation of the Commission's rule regarding possession of prohibited drug paraphernalia. We reverse, however, its finding that Paoli's horse carried a prohibited drug in his body. The case is remanded to the Board for the imposition of an appropriate penalty.
Affirmed in part; reversed in part ...