Appeal from the Order of the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County in case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Public Welfare v. Carol C. Mallory and Berks Title Insurance Company, No. 226.
David A. Scholl, for appellant.
Inez G. Lundy, Assistant Attorney General, with her Joseph F. Lynch, Deputy Attorney General, for appellee.
Judges Wilkinson, Jr., Mencer and Rogers, sitting as a panel of three. Opinion by Judge Rogers.
[ 51 Pa. Commw. Page 414]
The Department of Public Welfare (DPW) filed a complaint in equity in the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County naming as defendants the present appellant, Carol C. Mallory, and Berks Title
[ 51 Pa. Commw. Page 415]
Insurance Company. DPW alleged that Carol C. Mallory was the daughter of Lottie J. Mallory, deceased, the executrix of her mother's will and the owner by inheritance from her mother of a property in Philadelphia, the proceeds of the sale of which by Carol C. Mallory were in custody of the co-defendant Berks Title Insurance Company; that Lottie J. Mallory had received public assistance during her lifetime and that DPW had judgments against her; that Carol C. Mallory had also received public assistance but had refused to sign instruments which would have enabled DPW to take judgment; and that Carol C. Mallory has refused to pay either the claim against her mother's estate or the claim for assistance provided her. The relief requested was that Berks Title Insurance Company be enjoined from making distribution of the proceeds of Carol C. Mallory's property until DPW's claim to them was adjudicated and for judgment against Carol C. Mallory in the amount paid her by DPW.
Accompanying the complaint was a petition for preliminary injunction and an injunction affidavit, the latter stating "that there are sufficient grounds to believe that unless immediately enjoined from doing so, the defendant will demand distribution of said funds and evade payment of plaintiff's claim."
The complaint, petition and injunction affidavit were filed on December 5, 1978. By decree dated December 6, 1978 a judge of the court below issued a preliminary injunction without written notice to or hearing afforded Carol C. Mallory enjoining Berks Title Insurance Company from making any distribution of the funds in its custody and fixing December 11, 1978 as a time for hearing on the continuance of the injunction. On December 11, 1978 another judge of the court below, to whom the matter of the hearing on continuance had been assigned, met in chambers
[ 51 Pa. Commw. Page 416]
with counsel for DPW and Berks Title Insurance Company. David A. Scholl, Esquire, who is associated with Community Legal Services, Inc., who had represented Carol C. Mallory, apparently with respect to the sale of the real estate and who had learned of the injunction and conference from counsel for Berks, also attended some part of the meeting in chambers. We learn from the judge's memorandum opinion filed in March 1979 that Mr. Scholl said that he was not authorized to enter an appearance for Carol C. Mallory and that the judge thereupon did not permit him to participate in the conference on Carol C. Mallory's part. A notice of the December 11, 1978 scheduled hearing sent to Carol C. Mallory to an address in Syracuse was returned unclaimed. Obviously, no hearing was held on December 11, 1978 as ordered.
By order dated December 19, 1978, the judge who conducted the conference on December 11, 1978 directed that Berks Title Insurance Company should pay DPW the amount necessary to satisfy a judgment against Lottie J. Mallory (a form of relief not requested in the complaint) and that Berks Title Insurance Company should hold the balance of the funds in escrow pending further order of court. No time for ...