Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

SCHOOL DISTRICT CITY YORK v. B. WILLIAM ALLISON (10/17/79)

decided: October 17, 1979.

SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF YORK, PETITIONER
v.
B. WILLIAM ALLISON, RESPONDENT



Appeal from the Order of the Secretary of Education in case of B. William Allison v. School District of the City of York, Teacher Tenure Appeal, No. 34-77.

COUNSEL

Nevin Stetler, with him Stetler & Gribbin, for appellant.

Gerald E. Ruth, for appellee.

Judges Blatt, DiSalle and Craig, sitting as a panel of three. Opinion by Judge DiSalle.

Author: Disalle

[ 46 Pa. Commw. Page 521]

Presently before us is a petition for review filed by the School District of the City of York (School District) from the order of the Secretary of Education (Secretary) sustaining the appeal of B. William Allison and remanding the case for a hearing on the reasons for Allison's demotion.*fn1

[ 46 Pa. Commw. Page 522]

The School District first challenges the Secretary's determination that the re-assignment of Allison from Principal of Jackson Elementary School to Principal with Auxiliary Duties at the Franklin and McKinley Elementary Schools constituted a demotion. By now, of course, it is axiomatic that unless an error of law has been committed or any necessary finding of fact is not supported by substantial evidence, we must affirm the Secretary's action.

Where, as here, we are concerned with a possible demotion in type of position, even though the salary remains the same, an inquiry into the importance, dignity, responsibility, authority and/or prestige between the former and the latter positions is necessary. Department of Education v. Kauffman, 21 Pa. Commonwealth Ct. 89, 343 A.2d 391 (1975). The Secretary, in undertaking an analysis of the two positions at issue in this case, concluded that Allison was in fact demoted since he would be less than completely in charge of the supervision and administration of the schools to which he had been assigned and that since the Franklin and McKinley Elementary Schools were the only two in the school district which did not have assistant principals or administrative assistants, a lowering of his status in the educational hierarchy had occurred. We are in agreement with the Secretary that these differences are indeed substantial and amount to a demotion.

Although the Superintendent testified that Allison's duties were to be those of a principal, the official

[ 46 Pa. Commw. Page 523]

    job description provides that the principal shall have "complete charge of the administration and supervision of the building to which he is assigned." As Principal of Jackson Elementary School, he was solely in charge of its affairs. In his new position, however, Allison will have to share his duties with the two principals who continue to head Franklin and McKinley Elementary Schools. This division of responsibilities, which as of the date of the hearing was still not finalized, is certainly a diminution in authority.

Furthermore, as the Secretary aptly noted, Allison is in a singular position as a principal within the school district. Not only must he now share duties which he formerly performed alone, but, in contrast to the two schools to which he has been assigned, the remaining elementary schools each have assistant principals or administrative assistants. It takes little imagination to conclude that Allison is in effect being asked to assume the duties of an assistant principal of two schools since the Superintendent testified that assistant principals can perform the same duties as a principal. But of more moment is the fact that, ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.