No. 982, October Term, 1977, Appeal from the Judgment of Sentence of the Court of Common Pleas, Criminal Division, of Lancaster County, Nos. 3274, 3275 of 1975.
Edward F. Browne, Jr., Assistant Public Defender, Lancaster, for appellant.
D. Richard Eckman, District Attorney, Lancaster, for Commonwealth, appellee.
Watkins, President Judge, and Jacobs, Hoffman, Cercone, Price, Van der Voort and Spaeth, JJ. Price, J., dissents. Watkins, former President Judge, did not participate in the consideration or decision of this case.
[ 256 Pa. Super. Page 64]
Appellant contends that (1) 18 Pa.C.S. § 906*fn1 precludes
[ 256 Pa. Super. Page 65]
convictions for both attempted theft*fn2 and possession of an instrument of crime with intent to employ it criminally*fn3 when both offenses were designed to culminate in the commission of the same crime, and (2) the lower court erred in denying his motion for a mistrial after some jurors allegedly observed appellant in handcuffs. Because we agree with appellant's former contention, we vacate the judgments of sentence and remand for resentencing.*fn4
On November 16, 1975, Lancaster County officials arrested appellant and charged him with criminal conspiracy,*fn5 two counts of theft by unlawful taking,*fn6 attempted theft, and possession of an instrument of crime with intent to employ it criminally. From May 27-June 1, 1976, appellant was tried before a jury in the Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas. The Commonwealth presented evidence which showed that at about 2:00 a. m., on November 16, 1975, appellant and two co-defendants attempted to steal several thousand dollars worth of cable stored in a locked and enclosed area of a Bell Telephone Company lot in Lancaster. The police, who had staked out the lot because of a series of previous thefts of cable, arrested appellant inside this enclosed area; appellant possessed wire and bolt cutters, hacksaws, cable cutters, wrenches, and other tools. The lower court granted appellant's demurrer to the two charges of theft by unlawful taking but the jury returned the verdict of guilty on all other charges. In response to appellant's
[ 256 Pa. Super. Page 66]
specific written post-verdict motions, the lower court arrested judgment on the conspiracy conviction, but affirmed all other convictions. On January 28, 1977, the lower court sentenced appellant to concurrent 11 1/2-23 month terms of imprisonment for attempted theft and possession of an instrument of crime. This appeal followed.
Appellant contends that 18 Pa.C.S. § 906 proscribed his conviction and punishment for both attempted theft and possession of an instrument of crime with intent to employ it criminally. 18 Pa.C.S. § 906 provides: "A person may not be convicted of more than one offense defined by this chapter [Chapter 9 on inchoate crimes] for conduct designed to commit or to culminate in the commission of the same crime." 18 Pa.C.S. § 906 stems verbatim from the Model Penal Code, § 5.05(3).*fn7 The accompanying commentary to the Model Penal Code section explains the reason for its adoption. "The provision reflects the policy, frequently stated in these comments, of finding the evil of propatory action in the danger that it may culminate in the substantive offense that is its object. Thus conceived, there is no warrant for cumulating convictions of attempt, solicitation and conspiracy to commit the same offense." Tentative Draft No. 10 at p. 180. See also Commonwealth v. Greiner, 64 Lancaster L.Rev. 268 (1974); S. Toll, Pa. Crimes Code Annot. at 270 (1974); Comment, Criminal Law: Criminal Conspiracy under the New Pennsylvania Crimes Code, 78 Dickinson L.Rev. 159, 174 (1973).
Both attempted theft and possession of an instrument of crime are inchoate crimes under chapter nine of the Crimes Code. 18 Pa.C.S. § 901 defines criminal attempt as follows: "A person commits an attempt when, with intent to commit a specific crime, he does any act which constitutes a substantial step toward the commission of that crime." 18 Pa.C.S. § 907(a) renders illegal ". . . [possession of] any instrument of crime with intent to employ it ...