Appeal from the Order of the State Civil Service Commission in case of In Re: Appeal of John R. Rickers, No. 1254.
Graham C. Showalter, for appellant.
Sidney V. Blecker, Assistant Attorney General, with him Marx S. Leopold, Assistant Attorney General, and J. Shane Creamer, Attorney General.
Judges Crumlish, Jr., Wilkinson, Jr., and Mencer, sitting as a panel of three. Opinion by Judge Crumlish, Jr.
This is an appeal from an adjudication and order of the Pennsylvania Civil Service Commission which sustained the action of the Department of Public Welfare in suspending and removing appellant from his position as Child Care Aide I, regular status, at Laurelton State School and Hospital (Laurelton). The suspension and removal had been imposed by the appointing authority (Dept. of Public Welfare) because of an incident of patient abuse.
Appellant was working in Cottage 5 at Laurelton on February 11, 1972, in the early morning when a patient, Edward Vogel, shouted an obscenity at him. The patient had a record of previous outbursts and his program of therapy dictated that he be placed in seclusion upon any such outburst. The method of attaining that end is the bone of contention in this appeal.
Appellant contends, and so testified at a hearing before the Commission, that he approached the patient, had his glasses knocked off, summoned the help of two Aide Trainees, and proceeded along with the two trainees to bring the patient into a seclusion room. Appellant denied ever striking the patient, kicking him or generally using excessive force in subduing the patient. It was agreed that the patient was flailing and kicking.
The two Trainees were working in a room next to appellant that was connected by a door whose glass had been broken shortly before.*fn1 One, Trainee Spielman, testified that he heard the patient make the obscene remark and then heard appellant reply, "You can't talk to me that way." Although not summoned, he came out and then observed the appellant struggling on the floor with the patient at which time the appellant struck the patient forcefully in the mouth with his fist. The other, Trainee Brooke, testified that he heard the remark, turned to remove his glasses and went to appellant's aid although not summoned. He did not see the appellant strike the patient but said this was possible as he had turned to remove his glasses.
Both Trainees helped the appellant carry the patient to a seclusion room and both observed that the
patient's mouth was bleeding at the time. Both testified that appellant then pushed and kicked the ...