Searching over 5,500,000 cases.

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Official citation and/or docket number and footnotes (if any) for this case available with purchase.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.



decided: September 15, 1966.


Appeal from judgment of Court of Quarter Sessions of Philadelphia County, Dec. T., 1964, No. 534, in case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Herbert Price.


Robert F. Simone, for appellant.

James D. Crawford, Assistant District Attorney, with him Joseph M. Smith, Assistant District Attorney, and Arlen Specter, District Attorney, for Commonwealth, appellee.

Ervin, P. J., Wright, Watkins, Montgomery, Jacobs, Hoffman, and Spaulding, JJ. Opinion by Jacobs, J.

Author: Jacobs

[ 208 Pa. Super. Page 355]

Herbert Price appeals from the judgment of sentence imposed following a conviction of arson. The facts of this case as well as most of the governing principles of law are discussed in Commonwealth v. Reginelli, 208 Pa. Superior Ct. 344, 222 A.2d 605 (1966).

Price appeals on the grounds that the evidence was insufficient to sustain the conviction and that the rebuttal testimony to the effect that Reginelli admitted having known him was prejudicial to his case, even though by ruling of the court it was admitted against Reginelli only.

[ 208 Pa. Super. Page 356]

In addition to our discussion in the Reginelli opinion of the sufficiency of the evidence presented in this trial, Price's involvement could be further inferred from his statement when he was given one-third of the $2,000, "I get more than this, don't I? I'm not going to settle for this." Edward Klayman also testified that Price reassured Reginelli in these words: "Don't worry about the Fire Marshal's office. And don't worry about the police. We're professionals. We know what we're doing. . . . You don't have to think about the prosecution. They don't know what's in your mind. You are insured for arson. But we are professionals. We know what we use, and it's undetectable, believe me."

Admittedly, there is no direct evidence of Price's guilt; only Klayman's testimony implicates him in any way. We discussed Klayman's competence in the Reginelli opinion. The weight to be given Klayman's testimony was for the lower court. Following the tests we set forth in Reginelli, we affirm the lower court's judgment.

Price's second argument was never raised until the day of argument before this court, which means that we look only to see whether fundamental error was committed. We are not persuaded that it was. The rebuttal testimony complained of tended to contradict Reginelli's assertion that he did not know Price at the time of the fire or at the time he collected the $2,000 from the insurance adjuster. It was not a confession and did not go to the elements of the crime as the confession did in Commonwealth v. Oister et al. (Brockerman's Appeal), 201 Pa. Superior Ct. 251, 191 A.2d 851 (1963), relied on by Price. Nor was a severance requested here, as it was in Oister. The testimony was stricken as regarded Price and was admitted only against Reginelli. The evidence was considered by an experienced trial judge. We are satisfied that by striking

[ 208 Pa. Super. Page 357]

    the statements as regarded Price, Judge Griffiths indicated that he was not considering the testimony in deciding Price's guilt or innocence. A trial judge, unlike a layman, knows that testimony may be considered only for the purpose for which it is admitted and must be ignored for any other purposes. See Commonwealth v. Rouse, 207 Pa. Superior Ct. 418, 218 A.2d 100 (1966), allocatur refused, Pa. Superior Ct.

Judgment of sentence affirmed and it is ordered that the appellant appear in the court below at such time as he may be there called and that he be by that court committed until he shall have complied with his sentence or any part thereof which had not been performed at the time the appeal in this case was made a supersedeas.


Judgment affirmed.


© 1998 VersusLaw Inc.

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Official citation and/or docket number and footnotes (if any) for this case available with purchase.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.