Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Official citation and/or docket number and footnotes (if any) for this case available with purchase.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

FOREST HILLS BOROUGH APPEAL. (01/08/63)

THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA


January 8, 1963

FOREST HILLS BOROUGH APPEAL.

Appeal, No. 252, March T., 1962, from order of County Court of Allegheny County, No. A-1724 of 1961, in re appeal of Dance Oil Service, Inc. and William J. Reich from decision of Zoning Board of Adjustment of Borough of Forest Hills. Order affirmed.

COUNSEL

Warren S. Reding, with him Walter J. Phillips, and Reding, Blackstone & Sell, for appellant.

Frank Reich, with him Abraham Fishkin, for appellee.

Before Bell, C.j., Musmanno, Jones, Cohen, Eagen, O'brien and Keim, JJ.

Author: Bell

[ 409 Pa. Page 393]

OPINION BY MR. CHIEF JUSTICE BELL

The Borough of Forest Hills appeals from an Order of the County Court of Allegheny County which overruled the decision of the Board of Adjustment and granted a variance. The Court took additional testimony and therefore the question before this Court is whether there is adequate evidence to support the findings of the Court below and whether there has been a clear abuse of discretion or an error of law: Garbev

[ 409 Pa. Page 394]

    property. This belongs to and is used by the Wilkinsburg-Penn Joint Water Authority. According to the evidence, the Authority is unwilling to have this pipe either covered or moved. Moreover, on the property are two storm sewer lines crossing the property at right angles to Ardmore Boulevard. These are open galvanized pipes having diameters of approximately 18 inches, which empty into Fall Run. The "fill" for the plateau along the easterly side of Ardmore Boulevard was placed there approximately 5 years ago.

The evidence in the case fully warranted the conclusion of the Court below that for the above mentioned and other reasons the "residential" portion of the Reich property cannot be used for single family residences. Furthermore, a setback ordinance prevents an owner from building within the first 30 feet of the front line of the property. There was evidence that a one-family dwelling would occupy another 25 or 30 feet of depth. If the property is left the way it now is, there would be practically no available space between the rear of any future dwelling and the sharp declivity at the easterly edge of the present plateau along the easterly side of Ardmore Boulevard. Also, the declivity at the rear of the property and the Fall Run Gulley make the property not only an eyesore, but very dangerous for any owner who has young children.

There was expert testimony (1) that it would be vain to hope to obtain F.H.A. or V.A. financing for residences built on ground so recently filled, and any such buildings would require pilings or caissons at tremendous expense; (2) that filling in the eastern part of the property would be almost impossible because of the water pipe and storm sewers above referred to and because of Fall Run, but that if the easterly portion of the lot were filled in so as to be level with the westerly part, the cost of such fill would be approximately $80,000.00.

[ 409 Pa. Page 396]

The evidence clearly supports the findings of the Court below that this property cannot be used for the erection of one-family dwellings, which is the sole permissible use under the zoning regulations. It is crystal clear that the owner has proved unnecessary hardship which is peculiar and unique to this property. For all practical purposes the owner has been deprived of the lawful use of his property by an ordinance which in its application to this property is arbitrary, unreasonable, discriminatory and confiscatory, and therefore unconstitutional: Garbev Zoning Case, 385 Pa., supra.

Disposition

Order affirmed.

19630108

© 1998 VersusLaw Inc.



Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Official citation and/or docket number and footnotes (if any) for this case available with purchase.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.