Appeal, No. 186, Jan. T., 1958, from decree of Court of Common Pleas No. 7 of Philadelphia County, March T., 1955, No. 6672, in case of Wilfred G. Bauer et al. v. Rhode Island Insurance Co. et al. Decree affirmed.
I. Finkelstein, for appellants.
John R. McConnell, with him Charles C. Hileman, III, and Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, for appellee.
Before Jones, C.j., Musmanno, Arnold, Jones and Cohen, JJ.
OPINION BY MR. CHIEF JUSTICE JONES
The plaintiffs, in behalf of themselves as well as any other creditors of Rhode Island Insurance Co. who might desire to join them, sued the Insurance Company, a Rhode Island corporation, in the court below, joining as defendants the Wm. Penn Fire Insurance Co., a Pennsylvania corporation, which is a debtor of the Rhode Island Insurance Co., upon a note for $100,000 whereof the remaining defendant, Doeskin Products, Inc., is a guarantor. The affairs of the Rhode Island Insurance Co. are now, and for a number of years have been, in the hands of a receiver appointed by a court of the corporation's domicile.
In the instant case, the plaintiffs, by their amended complaint in equity, prayed (1) appointment of an ancillary receiver of the assets in Pennsylvania of the Rhode Island Insurance Co., (2) an injunction restraining the Wm. Penn Fire Insurance Co. from paying over or transferring any funds, property or assets to the Rhode Island Insurance Co., save under the order of the court, (3) an injunction restraining Doeskin Products, Inc., from paying to Rhode Island Insurance Co. any of the indebtedness owed by the Wm. Penn Insurance Co. upon its note and (4) further injunctive relief in cognate connection.
After a hearing, the learned chancellor found that the only remaining asset in Pennsylvania owed to or claimed by the domiciliary receiver of the Rhode Island Insurance Co. is a disputed claim of $24,000 against the Wm. Penn Fire Insurance Co.; that the promissory note evidencing the $100,000 indebtedness of the Wm. Penn Fire Insurance Co. to the Rhode Island Insurance Co. is physically located in Providence, Rhode Island, in the possession of the domiciliary receiver who is subject to the jurisdiction of a Rhode Island court; and that the plaintiffs are creditors of the insolvent company in the sum of $1,255.56 for which they have received and accepted from the domiciliary liquidator dividend checks in partial distribution on account of their proven claim. It cannot be seriously disputed that the chancellor's findings of fact are supported by the evidence; and it is equally incontrovertible that the conclusions of law which the chancellor applied thereto are well founded.
The chancellor concluded, as a matter of law, on the basis of our decision in Commonwealth ex rel. v. Consolidated Indemnity and Insurance Company, 362 Pa. 561, 67 A.2d 434, that the only thing for an ancillary receiver in Pennsylvania to do would be to
transfer forthwith to the domiciliary receiver assets of the insolvent company collected in this State. The chancellor further concluded that, since there are practically no assets of Rhode Island Insurance Co. left in Pennsylvania, the facts did not warrant the appointment of an ancillary receiver for any purpose. Accordingly, the chancellor entered a decree nisi dismissing the complaint at the plaintiffs' costs. Exceptions ...