Appeal, No. 16, Feb. T., 1956, from judgment of Court of Common Pleas of Lackawanna County, Sept. T., 1954, No. 647, in case of Michael Krisovich v. Scranton Spring Brook Water Service Company and John Booth, Inc. Judgment affirmed.
Matthew D. Mackie, with him Welles & Mackie, for appellant.
A. Homanich, with him George A. Yavorek and Homanich, Dutka & Yavorek, for appellee.
Before Rhodes, P.j., Hirt, Gunther, Wright, Woodside, Ervin, and Carr, JJ.
Spring Brook Water Service Company supplies water and gas to users in various parts of Lackawanna County. On April 30, 1953, this company entered into a contract with John Booth, Inc., for the laying of an eight inch gas main along the west line of Ridge Road between the Borough of Jermyn and Dickson City. The contract provided for the excavation of a ditch about four feet deep and two feet wide, and the tamping of the backfill by mechanical means after the laying of the pipe. In the Borough of Blakely the gas line was laid within the boundaries of a dirt sidewalk. Between 5 and 6 p.m. on October 29, 1953, plaintiff, on his way home from a bakery shop, was walking on the sidewalk along Ridge Road in the Borough when without warning the earth suddenly subsided under him and his right leg for its entire length, up to the crotch of his body, became trapped in mud and water in the trench which had been backfilled by the defendant construction contractor. The plaintiff was unable to extricate himself, and the more he struggled the more firmly his leg became embedded in the mud in the trench. It required the combined efforts of three men, over a period of 25 minutes, to remove the material which held him fast and to pull him out of the hole. He was conscious of pain in his groin as he struggled to free himself and from his strained position, with one leg buried in the trench, he suffered a direct right traumatic inguinal hernia. The hernia was reduced by surgery but he was unable to resume his work as a coal miner until January 19, 1954.
In the present trespass action plaintiff recovered a verdict for $2,500 against the defendant John Booth, Inc., alone. In the light of the verdict we must take it that the trench had been backfilled shortly before plaintiff's injury, but there is nothing in the case which
suggests that the dangerous condition was discernible or that plaintiff knew or had reason to know of it. Plaintiff as a member of the traveling public was entitled to use the dirt path and, in the absence of manifest danger, to assume that the backfilling of the ditch had restored it to a state of reasonable safety. The construction contract called for tamping the fill in six inch layers and the evidence is that water could not have accumulated in the trench in volume sufficient to cause the subsidence if the fill was of proper material and had been properly tamped. The verdict establishes that the trench at the point of the injury was not backfilled in accordance with the contract. The resulting dangerous condition was foreseeable by the defendant and that contractor is chargeable with negligence because of that fact. The question is whether this negligence, which proximately caused the injury, was actionable under the circumstances.
At the time of plaintiff's injury the work of laying the gas main had been accepted by the Spring Brook Company as full performance of the construction contract, and John Booth, Inc., was no longer in possession of the land upon which the work had been done. On these grounds defendant in this appeal contends that it is not liable. For the further reason that there was no privity of contract between John Booth, Inc., and the plaintiff the appellant asserts that it owed no duty to him. There is no merit in these contentions; the judgment entered on the verdict will be affirmed.
Liability of a construction contractor, under the rule of our early cases, was restricted to persons as to whom a contractual relationship existed. And a contractor was relieved from liability to a third person for its negligent act, when possession of the premises was surrendered by the ...