Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

COMMONWEALTH v. MCLAUGHLIN. COMMONWEALTH V. OSTRANDER (03/12/51)

March 12, 1951

COMMONWEALTH
v.
MCLAUGHLIN. COMMONWEALTH V. OSTRANDER



COUNSEL

John V. Diggins, Chester, for appellant.

William A. Burns, Media, for appellee.

Before Rhodes, P. J., and Hirt, Reno, Dithrich, Ross, Arnold and Gunther, JJ.

Author: Arnold

[ 168 Pa. Super. Page 444]

ARNOLD, Judge.

Defendants severally appeal from summary convictions for violation of a building ordinance of Upper Darby Township, Delaware County. The cases will be disposed of in one opinion

The ordinance in question, as amended in 1948, requires that all dwellings have a minimum of 384 square feet of space on the first floor. 'House trailer' is defined as 'Any vehicle [used] for living or sleeping purposes.' If so used 'for * * * more than thirty (30) days in any * * * year [it would] be considered as a single-family dwelling. * * *'

Defendants' house trailers were used for living and sleeping purposes for more than thirty days in one year and admittedly did not possess the minimum area on the first floor.

The defendants complain that their demurrers to the Commonwealth's evidence should have been sustained. The refusal to sustain the demurrers cannot be reviewed on appeal where the defendants offer evidence. Commonwealth v. Spanos, 167 Pa. Super. 629, 76 A.2d 243, and the cases therein cited. It is true that the evidence of the Commonwealth was somewhat shadowy as to the floor space of the respective house trailers, but the defendants offered evidence which clearly showed that the trailers in question did not have the required area.*fn1 The defendants' demurrers having been overruled, the question of the sufficiency of the

[ 168 Pa. Super. Page 445]

    evidence to convict must be based upon the whole record, including the evidence of the defendants.

Most of the contentions of the appellants were ruled adversely in Lower Merion Township v. Gallup, 158 Pa. Super. 572, 46 A.2d 35; allocatur denied by the Supreme Court; certiorari denied by the United States Supreme Court, 329 U.S. 669, 67 S.Ct. 92, 91 L.Ed. 591. In that case this Court held that a house trailer was simply a mobile house. Therefore the contention that the building ordinance of Upper Darby Township cannot be applied to house trailers must be overruled. The township is not bound to exempt house trailers from the requirements applicable to ordinary dwellings. In the Gallup case it was impossible for house trailers to conform to the building ordinance but the legislation was sustained.

The ordinance in question was authorized by the Act of 1931, P.L. 1206, 53 P.S. ยง 19092-1502, subd. XVIII, which gave to townships of the first class power to 'make regulations for the construction of new buildings * * * and to require that before the work begins municipal approval of the plans and specifications' shall be secured; and 'to classify buildings * * * according to the use to be made of them; [and] to specify the mode of construction of such different classes of buildings * * *.' The provision of the ordinance prescribing a minimum area for the first floor is within the purview of the Act in question. It tends, even though imperfectly, to prevent over-crowding of dwellings. The ordinance was enacted by virtue of the power delegated by the Act, and constitutes 'a law which purports to be an exercise of the police power * * * and the ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.